Choosing the best canoe seat can be a game-changer for your paddling experience. A well-designed seat not only provides comfort but also enhances mobility and stroke power.
The right canoe seat should offer stability, preventing unnecessary shifts that could affect your balance on the water. However, it shouldn’t compromise on portability – after all, you don’t want an extra burden while portaging. And with two kids in tow on most of our trips, every ounce counts!
In this guide, we’ll explore various types of seats available in the marketplace to help you identify the best canoe seat for your needs. Whether you’re embarking on an afternoon adventure at the cabin or heading deep into canoe country, there is a canoe seat that is perfect for you.
Exploring Different Types of Canoe Seats
From sturdy aluminum frames to plush fabric models, there are plenty of choices. The best canoe seat for really comes down to your canoing style and what you look to achieve.
One thing to note is that we are talking about traditional canoes, including kevlar canoes. If you have a kayak, inflatable boat, power boat, or are looking for something for your next sit-on-top kayaking adventure, then this article unfortunately is not for you.
The seats here are all designed to function best with a traditional cane canoe seat, not a tractor seats, bucket seats, or other kayak seats.
Spoiler alert! We think the Crazy Creek Canoe Chair III is the best canoe seat and most comfortable for long trips. Read on to learn why.
Aluminum Frame Seats
Aluminum frame seats are durable, great for folks with a larger frame, and most come with a comfortable seat cushion. However, their rigid structure can limit your paddle stroke as they make it harder to reach the sides of the canoe when paddling.
Wooden Frame Seats
If you dream of an old wood and canvas canoe, then wooden frame seats could be your best canoe seat option. These traditionalist-friendly seats evoke nostalgia from a forgotten time. They tend to be less comfortable and not as functional on long trips.
The Folding Ash Cane Canoe Chair from Harmony stands out with its classic appeal and durable design. While it looks great, it is best canoe seat for longer trips as it can be a little stiff.
Our favorite canoe seats are fabric seats. They all come with a cushioned seat pad made with a thick foam cushion and a high backrest design and make the best canoe seats for almost any type of paddling.
The best product on the market is the Crazy Creek Canoe Chair III. It is lightweight, portable, and comfortable. It also makes a great camp chair, emergency sleeping pad, and camp cushion.
Other options like the Kelty Camp Chair, ALPS Mountaineering Weekend Seat, and ALPS Mountaineering Explorer +XT Seat (discontinued) provide a high-quality nylon-covered foam seat pad, however they do not have built-in straps so they cannot be securely attached to your original canoe seat.
Pads And Cushions
Pads and canoe seats cushions are the best canoe seat options for those looking at affordable ways to add extra foam padding onto existing canoe benches. The Crazy Creek Canoe Pad is the same as the Canoe Chair III above, but without the back.
The key benefit of many of these options is the under-seat storage. There are many days I wish I had a tacklebox securely fastened under my seat!
Criteria for Choosing the Best Canoe Seat
Like any gear purchase, you need to determine your specific needs prior to determining the best canoe seat for your situation.
We recommend considering factors such as comfort, durability, adjustability, and portability. Remember that almost anything can be returned, so do your best, try it out, and return it if it doesn’t work!
The best canoe seats should provide sufficient cushioning to keep you comfortable during long days on the water. High-density foam, closed-cell foam or gel padding is preferred, regardless of the style of the frame.
The design of a seat also plays an integral role in comfort; some of the most comfortable canoe seats come equipped with contoured padded backrests that align with your spine’s natural curve, providing much-needed back support. If lower back discomfort is a concern or if you plan long hours out on the water, opt for high backrest designs, like those found in many sit-on-top kayaks.
The best canoe seats are able to withstand constant exposure to sun, rain, and wind. High-quality nylon or polyester are the best materials due to their resistance against the elements.
This is where paying up for well-known brands really pays off. While you may be able to find a cheaper option on Amazon, I highly doubt it will compete with the best canoe seats in terms of longevity!
We also recommend making sure your seat is adjustable. We all have different bodies, and the best canoe seats are the ones that are comfortable!
Long paddles in remote locations require lightweight gear, it’s just a fact of life. Look for that balance between comfort, durability, and weight. If you will be portaging, find seats that can stay strapped to the canoe during the portage like the GCI Outdoor Sitbacker and the Crazy Creek Canoe Chair III.
Top Picks For Best Canoe Seats With and Without Back Support
There are a lot of canoe seat options. Some are great, and some are downright junk. In our opinion, there really are only two options if you are looking for something with back support.
Crazy Creek Canoe Seat III:
The Crazy Creek Canoe Seat III is the best canoe seat in our opinioin. It offers exceptional comfort due in part to its thick foam cushioning and high backrest design.
The adjustable straps provide customization n, and the bottom straps firmly attach the seat to the canoe. It is lightweight, supportive, and easy to portage.
Crazy Creek also offers a long-back version if you are looking for a higher seat back.
GCI Outdoor Sitbacker Canoe Seat:
If you are OK with carrying a little extra weight, then the GCI Outdoor Sitbacker is another great option. It is the second best canoe seat in our opinion. The contoured padding is excellent and provides a slightly higher seat height (your hip flexors will thank you) and additional lumbar cushion.
The backrest is higher than the Crazy Creek version and the aluminum frame is more supportive, especially if you are on the taller or heavier side.
We see these deep in the Boundary Waters Canoe Area and have yet to find somene who thought the size or weight was a burden.
Other Canoe Seat Options:
We do see other options on the market from time to time offering back support, but to be honest they are not worth considering. Crazy Creek and GCI have been fine-tuning these seats for ages. They are affordable and will stand the test of time.
You may come across articles recommending some crazy brands on Amazon. Just pass. They will not last, and those with a canoe backrest are sure to disappoint. The quality just isn’t there.
Maintaining Your Canoes Seat’s Quality Over Time
To ensure our recommended seats continue delivering their promised benefits over time, proper maintenance is important.
Try to store them out of the elements when possible, and clean with a mild soap and warm water. Regular checks for signs of wear and tear like fraying webbing straps or loosened stitching can also help fix a problem before it gets too big!
Installation Your New Canoe Seats
Installing Your New Seat
A good canoe seat basically installs itself. They are custom made to fit the traditional bench seats found in most canoes. Both the Crazy Creek and GCI models have a dual buckle strap system that go under the original canoe seat and connect.
Our only advice is to make sure the new seat is tightly connected. Otherwise, you will feel it start to slide around as you begin paddling. It is much easier to tighten everything on dry land than in a fully loaded canoe!
FAQs in Relation to Best Canoe Seat
What is the best material for a canoe seat?
The best material for a canoe seat is typically high-density foam or gel padding, covered with durable fabric like nylon or polyester.
How can I make my canoe seat more comfortable?
Add comfort to your canoe seat by using high-density foam pads, cushions, or installing adjustable backrests. Seat covers also help.
Where is the best place to sit in a canoe?
In tandem canoes, the stern (back) offers better control and visibility while the bow (front) provides power and direction.
Is it better to kneel or sit in a canoe?
Kneeling lowers your center of gravity providing stability and power. Sitting allows easier paddling and is better for long distances. Choose based on conditions and personal preference.
The Best Canoe Seats – Conclusion
Whether you are a beginner or an experienced paddler, remember: The best canoe seat is the one that keeps you on the water the longest!
Check out More Camping Related Articles
Choosing the Best Family Canoe – Everything you need to know to choose your family’s next canoe
The Time We Forgot Our Tent – A fun story about a camping trip to George Crosby Manitou State Park in Minnesota when Dad forgot the tent.
How To Pack a Youth Survival Kid for Camping – Take a look at what our kids pack in their survival kits on backcountry camping trips
The BEST Beginner Trip to the Boundary Waters with Kids – Curious about going to the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness in Minnesota? This is the perfect trip for newbies or families with young kids.
The Best Boundary Waters Camp Saw for 2023 – Looking for a new camp saw? The Agawa Boreal 21 is our new favorite! Read to learn more.
We’d Love to Hear From You!
Let us know what you think in the comments, on Instagram, or on Facebook!